HAHAHAHAHAHAHA. That didn’t take me long. I was at it for a WHOLE 5 DAYS!
My husband was right, again. I hate it when he’s right.
To celebrate my failure, I’m treating my wounded ego to some leftover Halloween candy (mini gummi bears and fun-sized Snickers to be precise!)
β Relevant Reads:
- Frugality Is a Lifestyle That You Might Be Doing Wrong
- Facebook Bragging Can Be Annoying – And Ruin Your Finances Too
- Download Our Free Google Budget Sheet ?
Table of Contents
What I Did Accomplish:
- STAYED UNDER $30 – My total was $28.98 (groceries are tax-free, woo!) and I have enough food to last me for the remainder of the week. Sitting in my fridge currently is some chicken thighs, half a can of tomato paste, half an onion, half a bowl of green beans + carrots, lots of lentils and 7 imaginaryΒ eggs.
- STICKING TO ONE STORE – Overpriced but I made my bed, I had to sleep in it. *Grumbles about paying $2 for black pepper when Dollar Tree had it for $1…*
- LOST WEIGHT – My weight started at a high of 107.8.Β As of the 5th day, I’m currently 101.6 lbs. Yikes, more on that later.
- DID IT WHILE SICK – Yes, I still have that cold I mentioned last week. This is the longest I’ve ever held a cold.
Grocer’s List:
(First trip alone~)
Grapefruit – free leftover from Airbnb guest – (I ate 1/3 and tossed it. Grapefruits are gross.)
Hunt’s Tomato Paste – $0.99
Morton’s Salt – $0.59
Club House Pepper – $1.98 (robbery!)
12 AA Eggs – $1.39
Signature Kitchen Frozen Lasagna – $5.99
7 lbs of Chicken Thighs – $4.68 (actually a great deal!)
Yams/Sweet Potatoes – $2.99 for 1.33 lbs
1 Carrot – $0.79
Bananas – $0.87 for 1.47 lbs
1 lb Green Beans – $2.49/lb
Yellow Onion – $0.74 for 1.07 lbs (robbery!)
(I went to buy lentils and oil over the weekend. Second trip~)
Red Lentils (1 lb) – $3.49 (robbery…my Ethiopian grocer sells $3.29 for 3 lbs.)
Veg Oil (depressing…couldn’t afford olive oil and out of stock anyways…) – $1.99
Combined Total = $28.98
If groceries had taxes, I would definitely be over. Phew. I stuck it to one store (Albertson’s) and it was pricey in everything except the meat section. I couldn’t force myself to buy soy sauce at Albertson’s. The soy sauce at the Asian grocers are cheaper than the American grocer and I couldn’t swallow the price difference. Cheep cheep! π
β Related Reads:
- 3 Signs When Being Frugal Doesnβt Work & What To Do About It
- Why Rich People Penny Pinch When They Donβt Have To?
- At What Age Does Being Broke Stop Being Cute?
What I Ate:
November 1st
Breakfast: grapefruit + half a yam
Lunch/Dinner: half a yam and frozen lasagna at 4 PM.
November 2nd
Breakfast: banana
Lunch: half a yam + chicken thigh
Dinner: half a yam + 2 chicken thighs + egg
November 3rd
Breakfast: 2 bananas
Lunch: leftover dinner + half a yam
Dinner: frozen lasagna + green beans with carrots
November 4th
Breakfast: last banana
Lunch: lasagna + green beans
Dinner: last lasagna + chicken thigh
November 5th
Breakfast: half a yam + lasagna
Skipped lunch (out of sinus and tooth misery)
Dinner: chicken thigh + red lentils + last yam
November 6th
Breakfast: banana + leftover lentil
Skipped (tension in the kitchen between the old man)
3 egg omelette + candy
What I Have Left:
5 pieces of chicken thighs
Half a can of tomato paste
Lots of lentils
Half a onion
Half a bowl of green beans and carrots
7 Eggs
7 imaginary eggs – I was supposed to have 7 eggs left but my dad used them and there were only 4 eggs (including his eggs purchased before) in the fridge. He also used up some of the green beans and carrot I bought for his stir-fry. GRRRRRRRR.
I told him to not touch my things anymore but it’s hard for him to…listen? The story of my life. I mentioned in last week’s post, he just simply doesn’t understand it. Annnnd as usual, if he doesn’t understand something, I’m automatically “stupid” and he does whatever he wants. It’s this type of personable style I’ve come to terms with.
β Related Reads:
- 9 Money Mistakes To Avoid For Debt-Free Living
- Donβt (Nicolas) Cage Yourself In Financially
- 4 Practical Budgets For People Bad With Money
Weight Loss
Does “lose 6% of body weight in 5 days” sound like an overzealous weight loss commercial? Yeahhh, I don’t think that’s healthy either.
That is a crash diet, I’m not losing just fat, I’m losing the good stuff. I was thinking I would lose 1 pound a week or maybe even 2 pounds but over 6 lbs? No, I didn’t feel hunger or dizziness, really. I did not go hungry.Β I did hate salt and pepper chicken with steamed yams for days though. This girl ate until she felt full and stopped.
Crash dieting is a miserable experience. Itβs also pointless. Youβre suffering a lot, getting nowhere, and probably setting yourself up for failure (and even more serious problems). Skip the crash diets.
By the night of the 5th day, I quit. I quit in a fury by eating 3 fun-sized Snickers, 1 pack of M&Ms and plotted this post in my head on my way to the fridge for some cream cheese artichoke dip!!! I have no point to prove here.
Findings:
1) It’s misery. Yes…you can live on $30 a week and not die – but it will stink and you WILL lose weight. Especially in the beginning when you are limited in the basics.
2) Dropping weight this quickly is not good – I’ll keep to eating healthy and dropping to 100 lbs but the real and healthy way!
3) Busy families reach for quicker food even though they tends to be more expensive.
I think those were obvious from the start so what was I even doing this SNAP diet for?
It was not fun living on $30 a week. It is enough food for you to feed yourself but it’s not going to be considered a good meal in terms of taste if you’re setting up. The first thing I reached for after a tired long day was frozen lasagna. I ate bananas and yams first because they were easy to prep and grab. On the 2nd day, I remember thanking my brain for being smart enough to purchase some frozen lasagna in case I came home late because of a bad day. And guess what? The second day was a BAD day and I was so happy for easy to warm up lasagna.
Simulating busy, tired, overworked people like my parents…things like white rice and the repetitive staples is probably how my mom (she did the cooking after work) made it work for the family. On my tired day, I just threw something in the oven (or realistically, picked up a bucket of KFC chicken) – my mom didn’t have the budget for that option. Man…
βοΈ Related Reads:
- Would You Survive a Financial Recession If Economic Collapse Happened?
- I Took The 30 Day No Spend Challenge & This Is What I Learned
Why I Failed:
The glaring issue of why I failed can easily pinpoint the following…
- BAD SELF CONTROL – I ate 4 pieces of leftover Halloween candy yesterday and quit. (P.S. I told myself I will just deduct $1 from the $30 budget so technically, I should be at least at $29.98.)
- RAPID WEIGHT LOSS – I lost 6% of my body weight in 5 days and went into crash diet mode…which was not my intent at all.
- INTERFERENCE – Dad took carrots and yams out of my cart in the store, put them back thinking I wouldn’t notice. The old man doesn’t know what I’m trying to do (ie. buy bananas even though we have bananas at home.) I explained to him it’s “for work” but he doesn’t understand me/accept that. He used my groceries I told him not to touch. I will likely lose my mind if this continued.
- APATHYΒ – If you needed a prescription for apathy, it’s going to be trying to live on $30 a week with a yucky cold, snowing, without a car, dealing with two bad Airbnb guests back to back and then coming home to over-salted, over-cooked chicken.
- MULTIPLE TRIPS – I imposed just 1 grocery trip per week to cover what I needed but couldn’t live without oil so I went to the store again.
Remember the house warming party I mentioned in my 9 frugal wins & 3 frugal fails last week? There were some cough-y kids at that table with me, dad and hubby. They must have carried something, all 3 of us have the same pesky cold now with the same time of onset and same exact symptoms. Darn kids! My sinus infection is currently shooting pain down to my tooth. Ugh, misery. I’ll cut this post short and go to bed.
We’ll do this again someday, I think right around the corner of the week after never ever ever!!! Even without being sick, the old man and better planning – I wouldn’t do it unless you promised me princess cake at the end of EACH day.
For an awesome SNAP Challenge (done like a pro!) check out Doubling Dollars! Seriously, it’s harder than it looks! πΒ Mr. DD lost weight too so it’s norms in this challenge, but I don’t recommendΒ this “diet.”
Financial Freedom Starts With Saving:
Personal Capital: Sign up and use their net worth calculator for FREE. They are a free financial service platform that helps you analyze your portfolio, retirement, and financial health all on one simple & secure account
Imperfect Foods: We all need groceries. Try out Imperfect Foods to get $80 off ($20 off your first 4 orders.) Read my review of this revolutionary and money-saving grocery delivery service.
ThredUp: The only online recycle clothing store I currently shop and sell with. Great mission statement, company model, customer service, prices, and selection. Sign up with our invite link and you can get $10 free in ThredUP credit.
Survey Junkie: SJ is one of the few survey companies that are 100% legit, user-friendly, and great for making extra money. Earn up to $1,000 a month doing surveys online. You can make anywhere from $5-$20/day in your free time.
Grant @ Life Prep Couple says
Good for you for trying something new. Even though you technically “failed” you still learned something so that is a win.
Most of your weight loss is simply water from lowering your carbs so much. The water weight will come back as soon as you increase your carbs. Our bodies are smart enough not to eat up our precious muscle that quickly.
Lily says
I had that much water!? Maybe I should have counted calories…ahhhh this is embarrassing ?
Justin @ Atypical Life says
Your body is pretty much 50-60% water weight, so it is easiest to lose your weight via water. Just think of the wrestlers that run around in those ridiculous PVC sweat suits before competing to make their weight class. Sometimes I lose 10+ pounds on a single bike ride. Is that from burning calories? No, that is a very dangerous loss of water weight during the summer months.
PS. Why even bother with a diet? 107lbs is by no means heavy… Looking good π
Lily says
AHHH shucks Justin ^_^
GYM says
Awe at least you tried! I got so hungry reading what you ate, I would definitely need more than a banana and a yam to start my day. That’s too bad your dad took the food from your experiment π
I remember in an earlier post you said you disliked the same menu for meals and in the last 5 days it was a similar meal. Hope you feel better soon from your cold- drink lots of fluids!
Lily says
It was like being in foodie hell. Bananas and yams is what I’ll keep going forward, those were yummy and easy!
Mrs. Adventure Rich says
Grapefruits gross?!? How dare you utter such words… π
I have yet to try the SNAP challenge but it does sound harder than it looks. I would have a hard time cutting out my more expensive “regulars” (almonds, etc).
Lily says
I have never heard anyone defend grapefruit!!! It’s good for throwing! ? Almonds are so expensive, it would be a rare treat on the snap.
Yet Another PF Blog says
I’m impressed you were able to get through most of the week on $30. That in itself is a feat to be celebrated!
Like Grant said, if you were eating to satiety, you mostly lost water weight. It’ll bounce back pretty quickly once you reintroduce carbs and salt to your diet.
I’m sorry you had such a miserable time with the challenge. Hope you get over your cold soon!
Lily says
Aw I’m a bit sad I haven’t gotten near my goal weight then. I’ll continue tracking the weight and make an effort but SNAP itself, sayonora misery!
Ms. Frugal Asian Finance says
Yikes! I’m sorry to hear about the cold your family caught at the party. I knew you weren’t feeling well, but I didn’t know it was this bad. I’ve gotten sick 4 times this year bc Baby FAF got sick (probably from the daycare) and brought it home. I usually get sick once a year *sigh*
I know the challenge of having parents who don’t understand what we do and automatically assume we’re “stupid” because what we do differs from their way. I wonder if they thought the same way about us when we were kids and just wanted to do whatever we liked. @_@
Anyway, I’m glad you’re back to a normal diet. Feel better! xoxo
Lily says
Don’t worry about me sister, you get sick more often than I do. Kids really are germ carriers. I thought that was just a old joke but…no.. they’re sniffling infection monsters.
I just felt so silly about the eggs, do I have to deduct the missing eggs from the bill? What’s $1.29/12? Sigh, I just wanted to quit.
Mrs. Picky Pincher says
I’ve seen a few other people do the SNAP challenge and managed to maintain weight (a lot of people gain weight on it!). The key there is cheap grains like pasta, which aren’t healthy, but they’re SNAP budget-friendly, so I see that a lot. Could be a way to maintain weight (hey carbs!) while on a very low budget. Either way, it shows that it’s difficult to eat the things you want, stay healthy, and be full on a small budget.
Lily says
I definitely was wrong to skip carbs – what tripped me was just how’s bad the food is day in, day out. Ugh yuck!
Caroline says
At least you tried:) My only challenge is to try to stay away from sweets….and I can’t even manage that! Chocolate is just too good. Hope you feel better soon.
Lily says
Aha I saw your cheat day is Sunday! Great idea!
Pamela says
Mini snickers work for me. Only 1 day.
Lily says
How do you stop yourself from more?!
Sarah De Diego says
Dear Lily,
Even though you didn’t finish the project, you passed in my books. Good on you for realizing that this wasn’t for you right now and putting an end to it. I hope you’re feeling better soon.
As for your Dad, he sounds like quite the character π
Looking forward to all your future challenges.
Besos Sarah.
Lily says
I’m so sorry to let you down Sarah ^_^! I just couldn’t do it! No regrets, I love food!!
YES, he is…he is himself.
Sarah De Diego says
Dear Lily,
You did NOT let me down. In fact, quite the opposite. I admire you for trying and am relieved to hear that when things went “wrong”, you took a step back, reviewed the situation and at the risk of “succeeding”, you stopped the challenge.
Looking forward to what you come up with next.
Besos Sarah.
Dash2Retire says
Holy Cow! No wonder you lost weight! I think I eat more in 1 day then you did all week. Of course, maybe that explains MY weight! haha
Lily says
Ahaha π
Sylvia | Mommy Over Work says
Yeah, it impresses me how immigrant parents do it. They work harder than we do and manage to keep up a household. Here I am complaining after coming home from a desk job and in laws who cook for my husband and me that I’m tired.
I was intrigued to try this challenge after your previous post, but with these results, I’m not sure if I would be able to last either!
Lily says
Me too! I feel bratty complaining because I’m only doing half the work my mom was doing. I think I married a lot better though π π
Chris @ Duke of Dollars says
Nothing wrong with saying forget this! At least you tried and learned from it !
Lily says
Haha thanks Chris! It was miserable. Dieting alone was unexpectedly difficult!
Kris says
Hey at least you tried and figured out it wasn’t for you. I just had some mini snickers from treat-or-treating with Baby with Cents, those can get addicting. I’m more of a peanut M&M fan than plain.
Lily says
I love food too much than research π
Mr Groovy says
“Tension in the kitchen with the old man.”
LOL! You’re the best, Lily. Thanks for sharing your failure. It’s encouraging to know that even the great ones have an off week. And thanks for introducing me to the SNAP challenge. I wasn’t aware of it. It’s something I’d like to try. But I got to get permission from Mrs Groovy first. Otherwise there will be tension in the kitchen with the crazy redhead.
Lily says
Oh it would be epic if you do! Not the most nutritious or delicious diet out there. I fail all the time π not just this week Mr. G! I hope the Mrs doesn’t read your comment! :O
the Budget Epicurean says
Oh wow! I think in this case it’s totally acceptable to throw in the towel. As long as you realize what a blessing it is that this diet is a CHOICE for us! I only did mine for one week, and then donated the exact copy of the foods I ate to my local food bank. That’s a way you can keep the spirit of the post going. π Hilarious that your poor dad is just so confused. He’s probably thinking “why is she buying things we already have, things she never normally eats, and glaring at me for putting green beans in the stir fry?”
Lily says
I learned how blessed I was to be able to get off it. So I took full advantage of that. He’s even more confused today. I told him to help me eat the leftovers that I told him not to touch before haha. He thinks I’m trolling him xD
MrDoublingDollars says
Ah well, just by trying it out you have shown yourself to be more willing to do uncomfortable things than others are. I salute you for your efforts. ?
Lily says
I’m not even sure how you survived!! It’s so hard in a…”I just want a taco please sir” way.